Phase One Goes Down in Flames

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

by: the Common Constitutionalist

Scroll Down for Audio Version

I’ve been watching the tube (that’s a television, for all you younger readers) and listening to the radio, collecting reaction to the Ryan health insurance proposal. The Democrats aside – it seems there was strong support for the bill.

The establishment Republicans were all on board, as well as die hard Trump supporters.

Then there were the House Freedom Caucus members, who were firmly against it. The most vocal Senate opponents were the usual suspects and real conservatives, Mike Lee, Ted Cruz and Rand Paul. Count me in their camp.

Not surprisingly, virtually everyone on a certain cable news channel supported the Ryan bill – not for Ryan’s sake, but because president Trump was on board. What I did find a little surprising and a bit disturbing is that the majority of conservative radio talkers were also for the bill. Check that. They weren’t backing Ryan and the bill. They appeared to be on board in defense of Trump’s decision to support it. To me this seems misguided and frankly sycophantic.

I still hold that president Trump was sold a bill of goods by Republicans. Sure, he’s a smart guy, but even smart guys can be fooled.

We’ve heard that this was to be just the first of three phases to rid us of ObamaCare. Yet after being smoked by the Republicans year after year with broken promise after broken promise, it is astonishing that so many respected conservative talkers could think this time would be different, just because Trump is now at the helm.

Do they really think that there will be a phase two and three? And if there is, that it will resemble what Trump has promised?

The fact that none of the good stuff that Trump promised is in phase one should tell us something. The Republicans try to convince us that it must done in phases due to the complexity of the law and Senate rules and blah, blah, blah. I’m not buying this for a second. They give us lines such as the Senate Parliamentarian will not allow such and such legislation under Senate rules. This is a crock. The Parliamentarian only has such power because over the years the Senate has just accepted it as gospel.

It’s no different than the Legislative or Executive branches giving way to the Judicial without question. Also, the Parliamentarian, who is just supposed to be an adviser, not a judge and jury, can be overruled. In fact Fox News wrote that, “former Senate Parliamentarian Bob Dove confirmed the VP’s power to overrule, as do both experts in the Senate chamber — the chairman and Ranking Republican of the Budget Committee.” VP Mike Pence, as president of the Senate, can overrule the Parliamentarian. In other words, this was just another lame excuse not to act.

Late yesterday, after the RINOCare bill was pulled for a second and possibly last time, Speaker Ryan said, “I will not sugarcoat this. This is a disappointing day for us.” Yes – disappointing that you were unable to jam some phony legislation down our throats like so many of your predecessors have done.

“We learned a lot about loyalty. We learned a lot about the vote-getting process,” Trump told reporters at the White House Friday. Yes we did, Mr. President – and it’s about time.

I can only speak for myself, but I learned that there are just enough Republicans who appear to still be loyal to us and to the country, not the party, regardless of threatening consequences. This is refreshing, and gives me hope.

I would have loved to have supported the President, but I believe he was wrong to side with the establishment on this. History shows us that the Republican leadership in both Houses have proven themselves to be liars. Why should this time be any different.

I believe that if the Freedom Caucus truly believed there would be a phase two and three as promised, and in quick succession, they (and I) may have backed this measure. But the Leadership’s track record is such that they will get what they really want (or what the donors want) and find any excuse to go no further – with or without Trump’s influence.

If the defeat of this bill shows us anything, it is just what a bunch of sniveling weaklings the Republican establishment is. They had a clean, full repeal bill already written and passed just last year by a margin of 240-181. Trump would have signed it, but it was Ryan who refused to reintroduce it.

Congratulations, you jerk. You deserved to lose.

3 comments on “Phase One Goes Down in Flames

  1. I wish the people of Ryan’s state would recall him, then impeach him. he’s a phony liar, just like Boehner.

  2. As for the sycophantic members of so-called “conservative media”…a pox on them all. I support things because of their content not their sponsors and the content of this mess was…well, a mess.

    I have read disputes over whether the GOP actually did pass any full repeal. Many say they never did, that what they were passing and calling “full repeal” [as a show that they could if only we gave them a pres] was no such thing. Regardless, THIS wasn’t THAT.

    Some good folks have argued with me that this would have done the deed–fully get rid of Obamacare in a few years and it’s the only way we could get it done without even larger majorities. Somehow, we’re to believe that dems would agree to support “many” of the free market items in the supposed “phase III”…so why wouldn’t they support them NOW?

    If this is how it really–I mean REALLY and TRULY–has to be done then that is what they should have campaigned on instead of popping this on us then doing a bum’s rush to hurry it through.

    Full repeal, even with amendments delaying implementation of certain parts to allow free market to step into holes created, would require no “deregulation” phase, would it? Even all that kudzu strangling the trees will die if you yank it out by the danged roots. Kill the bill/law…the rules and regs have nothing on which to attach.

    The fact that there is so much confusion and disagreement over WTF was IN this thing is why it died. They didn’t take any time to pitch it properly, to explain it…to SELL it.

    So they come off looking …as usual…as shady operators, liars and scammers trying to pull a fast one.

    They deserved to lose this as poorly as they played it.

    They will get the chance to have a do-over if they don’t screw the pooch. Let Obamacare worsen–it will. Let enough of the people FEEL more pain from it then SELL relief–explain themselves instead of treating us all as idiots to be herded.

    As for Trump–he’s not stupid but he is willfully blind to anything he doesn’t see as impacting him or his biz/brand directly. That is changing slowly but the total absence of political [or moral] ideology other than “ME/Trump” self interest prevents him from devoting much time to thinking about things, developing an attachment to issues that would pique enough intellectual curiosity to make him need to KNOW. He still has no real grasp of just how different government is from private industry in process. product, procedure and overall impact on everyone. Sadly, his massive and oversensitive ego may well be his biggest obstacle to becoming ‘presidential’.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *